If anyone missed, fightonusc used a mathematical formula to determine a player's overall worth based on power, speed, contact. Please check out the results and comment:
http://dee-nee.com/wiki/index.php/Overall_Player_Rankings
Personally, I think it's a good idea but any system that has 5 players worse than Steve Lake is clearly flawed...
I used a similar idea but different forumula for drafting my Fantasy Team. Essentially my formula was:
[PWR-708] + [(38-CNT)*2] + [(SPD-118)*1.5]
However, as my team has hit like shit so far, this is probably useless:
NAME Adj Cnt Adj Pwr Adj Spd Total
Dawson 34 246 18 298
McGwir 40 234 12 286
Bell 48 228 9 285
Jacksn 30 237 15 282
Cansco 20 243 18 281
Murphy 42 201 21 264
EDavis 36 192 36 264
DaEvns 18 243 3 264
Baylor 18 216 27 261
Strwby 28 201 30 259
Gibson 36 186 30 252
J.Rice 56 183 12 251
Brnsky 30 198 18 246
Burks 20 180 33 233
Hrbek 44 186 3 233
WClark 50 174 9 233
Raines 54 135 42 231
Armas 20 210 0 230
Schmdt 36 183 9 228
Gaetti 26 183 18 227
Mldndo 46 168 12 226
JClark 36 183 6 225
Leonrd 44 156 24 224
Joyner 48 156 18 222
Mtngly 60 147 15 222
CDavis 28 165 27 220
Tramml 64 123 30 217
Lemon 34 174 6 214
Carter 38 171 3 212
DwEvns 22 183 6 211
Jones 12 183 15 210
DCincs 24 177 9 210
Brookn 8 189 12 209
Guerro 52 141 15 208
Dwning 36 159 9 204
Madlck 48 141 15 204
Pucket 64 114 24 202
Hndrsn 24 171 6 201
Herndz 54 135 9 198
Ripken 38 147 9 194
Mitchl 40 141 12 193
GDavis 24 159 9 192
Schfld 20 153 18 191
Gedman 34 153 3 190
Brett 52 126 9 187
Nokes 40 144 3 187
Hendrk 36 141 9 186
Laudnr 8 171 3 182
Whitkr 26 129 18 173
Shrdan 20 123 24 167
Boggs 68 81 15 164
Lopes 34 87 42 163
Lindmn 0 153 9 162
Heath 44 111 3 158
Brenly 34 111 12 157
McGee 40 81 33 154
Grich 34 111 9 154
Boone 28 123 3 154
Pndltn 38 90 24 152
Spilmn 28 123 0 151
K.Bass 48 72 30 150
Sntago 44 81 24 149
Garner 28 96 24 148
Wilfng 18 108 21 147
Knight 48 90 9 147
Burlsn 42 81 24 147
Heep 36 99 9 144
Dykstr 46 60 36 142
Colman 42 54 45 141
Johnsn 12 111 18 141
Gagne 32 99 9 140
Kruk 48 69 21 138
Speier 20 99 18 137
T.Pena 30 99 6 135
Yngbld 32 93 9 134
Wilson 40 63 30 133
Teufel 20 102 9 131
Baines 40 84 6 130
J.Cruz 40 60 30 130
Moltor 64 36 30 130
Bucknr 48 81 0 129
Morris 14 99 12 125
Sndbrg 38 63 24 125
Doran 40 57 27 124
Bush 24 81 18 123
T.Herr 32 63 27 122
Puhl 34 60 27 121
Aldrte 60 51 9 120
Pettis 36 51 33 120
Gladdn 36 51 33 120
Franco 54 33 33 120
Gwynn 62 21 36 119
Seitzr 48 51 18 117
D.Thon 20 75 21 116
Gllrga 52 51 12 115
Bergmn 30 81 3 114
Herndn 56 51 6 113
Rynlds 8 96 9 113
OSmith 46 27 39 112
Ford 32 60 18 110
Schrdr 56 51 3 110
Hatchr 22 51 36 109
Thmpsn 30 69 9 108
Wallng 50 42 15 107
Lmbrdz 14 81 9 104
JUribe 48 39 15 102
Larkin 32 63 6 101
Ashby 20 69 9 98
Oqendo 34 51 12 97
Barret 44 27 24 95
Smally 40 51 3 94
Davdsn 32 36 21 89
Rndlph 44 30 15 89
Mazzli 14 60 9 83
Sullvn 0 81 0 81
Lake 12 60 9 81
Pedriq 38 21 18 77
Backmn 56 9 9 74
S.Owen 8 27 21 56
Sntana 0 0 9 9
I don't need numbers to tell me how good a player is, I have my own two eyes!
Shooty's rankings have Sullivan over Lake, I'm going with it for now...
Quote from: fknmclane on 01/04/06, 03:33:35 PM
I don't need numbers to tell me how to pick a 2-2 Fantasy RBI team. Fuck you and your fancy math.
Why don't you kick my dog while you're at, huh?
This is how I have the rankings (using a computer).
The only player that comes out way off is Raines. IMO Raines shoud go b/w Baylor and Strawberry.
Dawson
Jacksn
DaEvns
Cansco
McGwir
Bell
Baylor
Strwby
Gibson
Murphy
EDavis
Brnsky
Armas
Hrbek
Jones
Burks
J.Rice
WClark
Gaetti
Brookn
CDavis
Schmdt
JClark
DwEvns
DCincs
Joyner
Lemon
Mldndo
Carter
Raines
Hndrsn
Leonrd
Mtngly
Laudnr
Dwning
GDavis
Schfld
Nokes
Gedman
Herndz
Ripken
Guerro
Madlck
Lindmn
Mitchl
Whitkr
Hendrk
Tramml
Shrdan
Brett
Pucket
Spilmn
Johnsn
Wilfng
Boone
Brenly
Grich
Heath
Pndltn
Morris
McGee
Lopes
Garner
Speier
Rynlds
Boggs
Heep
Teufel
Gagne
T.Pena
K.Bass
Baines
Bush
Knight
Yngbld
Sntago
Burlsn
Bucknr
Kruk
Bergmn
Dykstr
Wilson
Colman
T.Herr
J.Cruz
Puhl
D.Thon
Lmbrdz
Doran
Ashby
Pettis
Ford
Sndbrg
Larkin
Sullvn
Thmpsn
Aldrte
Mazzli
Gladdn
Hatchr
Oqendo
Smally
Seitzr
Wallng
Gllrga
Lake
Herndn
JUribe
OSmith
Schrdr
Moltor
Franco
Gwynn
Davdsn
S.Owen
Barret
Rndlph
Pedriq
Backmn
Sntana
QuoteThis is how I have the rankings (using a computer).
What exactly do you mean by "using a computer"? What is the formula you used?
Quote from: Gantry on 01/05/06, 11:32:36 AM
QuoteThis is how I have the rankings (using a computer).
What exactly do you mean by "using a computer"? What is the formula you used?
He just asked the computer to rank them, that computer is overvaluing Power to a certain extent.
Quote from: Gantry on 01/05/06, 11:32:36 AM
QuoteThis is how I have the rankings (using a computer).
What exactly do you mean by "using a computer"? What is the formula you used?
Random number generator. Comes out pretty good, huh?
Actually,
http://forums.dee-nee.com/index.php?topic=7003.msg114563#msg114563