Dee-Nee Forums

Eh, still not sure how to handle this.....

To recap, both finished with 29 points.
Tudor was included on 6 ballots, Baylor on 8.

Tudor will get my vote on account of him being on my original ballot.  I suggest those who voted for either would vote for thier guy here as well.  If it plays out that way then the rest of the voters(who had neither on a ballot) will do thier part to decide which one makes it on. 

I failed to set a date this puhl expires and can't seem to edit that.  You have until tuesday jan 8th at 7:30 am CDT to vote.(gantry/nightwulf...can any of you edit this issue?) 

Tudor gets my vote.    He's a top 3 to 5 pitcher on the game and he can shut down even the best hitters.

I think JoeDirt is a Tudor guy and that speaks volumes.

are you saying Tudor throws a spitter?

I go with Tudor as well - a truly unique pitcher while Baylor gets lost in the shuffle on that incredible BoSox lineup.  Heck, there are a bunch of folks who don't even think that Baylor is the best player on his team...

Baylor!

He is the best hitter on arguably the best offensive team on the game.

baylor is like the 7-8 best hitter in the game.  tudor is the top 1-2 pitcher.  i'd say that tudor is a lot more important to his team than baylor is to his.  also, just looking at the strength of the league, i think tudor rates above baylor.  admitedly, it's still a tough call.

baylor!!

Baylor is one of my top 5 favourite hitters.  Great power and speed combo.

Tudor.  And it isn't even close.

Quote from: fknmclane on 01/05/08, 08:36:12 PM
Tudor.  And it isn't even close.

12.5 + hours left for the puhl.....

Baylor is getting his ass kicked.  I wonder if he'll cry like a bitch.

racists.

Tudor rolls 13-5 in the puhl...4th HOF spot, here he comes

The people have spoken...