Dee-Nee Forums

General => RBI Baseball => Topic started by: Big Apple RBI Champ on 08/06/02, 07:00:07 AM

Title: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Big Apple RBI Champ on 08/06/02, 07:00:07 AM
Here's what happened in yesterday's game- you tell me the correct baseball ruling.

With runners on 1st and 3rd and 2 outs, the batter hit a high pop up in the infield.  The runner from third ran home and waited patiently on the Tengen home plate.  The runner on first dilly-dallied, assuming the inning would be over.

The third baseman missed the pop up (not a boink or a bop)- it just dropped in front of him.  When the ball dropped, the runner at home got credit for a run and scurried into the dugout.  However, the third baseman collected himself, picked the ball up and FORCED the runner at second base.

Clearly, the run should not have counted, right?

Is this considered a "glitch?"
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Dykstra-holic on 08/06/02, 08:24:24 AM
A GLITCH.

Although it was cute of the Tengen programmers to have the runner wait patiently in front of homeplate, the run should not count.  

See Merkle's Boner in late September of '08 versus the Cubs at the Polo Grounds.

Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Gwynn3k on 08/06/02, 02:45:06 PM
the programmers forgot that a 3rd out force at any base nullifies a run scoring regardless of timing...  therefore, if the runner gets to first, tengen rules allow the run to score...in the real world, this would not happen.
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: madlock_off_bench on 08/07/02, 04:48:35 AM
true, the run counts.  Glitches are a part of the game, just like the curve ball and errors should be a part of every RBI contest
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Gantry on 08/07/02, 05:58:27 AM
Interesting glitch that I never really thought about, well done.  It'll get added to the page soon....
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Blyleven_No-No on 08/07/02, 09:19:50 AM
We had an interesting glitch in last night's game, pop up to the left the fielder boinks the ball but somehow, he caught the ball before it hit the ground.  It was registered as an out, as if he caught it on the fly.  I had never before seen this happen with a boink
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Gantry on 08/07/02, 10:58:12 AM
Wow, that is a new one!!  Looks like I have two glitches to add....
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Big Apple RBI Champ on 08/07/02, 11:15:36 AM
wow blyleven- i have never seen that before.

when is the next nyc tourney????
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Dykstra-holic on 08/07/02, 11:46:46 AM
Bly_No-No was smokin' that tweed.
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: Dykstra-holic on 08/07/02, 12:00:08 PM
and I agree, all's fair game in an RBI matchup.  Except for excessive pressing "pause" or throwing a pitch before "player 2" can make a timeout to substitute.
Title: Re: RBI Glitch or MLB Rule?
Post by: MR RBI on 05/30/05, 10:01:08 PM
I think its part of the game...Remember it is not real....