Dee-Nee Forums

General => RBI Baseball => Topic started by: TecmoGuy on 11/22/04, 06:44:57 PM

Title: If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: TecmoGuy on 11/22/04, 06:44:57 PM
For instance, if a leadoff guy has a 12 contact, and a 750 power, does that make him shitty?  Since contact has nothing to do with average, I was curious.
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: GreatScott on 11/22/04, 07:03:02 PM
such a play would blow like JUribe or Marty Barrett
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: BeefMaster on 11/22/04, 07:28:30 PM
Quote from: josephady on 11/22/04, 06:44:57 PM
For instance, if a leadoff guy has a 12 contact, and a 750 power, does that make him shitty?  Since contact has nothing to do with average, I was curious.

I'd say he's shitty - contact only determines how much is subtracted from his power if he doesn't make solid contact.  His best is still worse than a guy with 800 power and 40 contact.
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: Flood on 11/22/04, 08:10:16 PM
Who is this "I guy" I've been hearing so much about lately?  
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: BeeJay on 11/22/04, 09:11:18 PM
Quote from: CurtFlood on 11/22/04, 08:10:16 PM
Who is this "I guy" I've been hearing so much about lately?  

He obviously sucks if he has no power.  Fuck I guy.
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: Bonny on 11/22/04, 10:45:13 PM
Everybody is gonna suck on my 1927 rom
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: BeeJay on 11/22/04, 10:49:43 PM
Quote from: Bonny on 11/22/04, 10:45:13 PM
Everybody is gonna suck on my 1927 rom
Especially I guy, he fucking blows.
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: ultimate7 on 11/23/04, 08:13:11 AM
Quote from: Bonny on 11/22/04, 10:45:13 PM
Everybody is gonna suck on my 1927 rom

I'd worry more about your 1917 ROM, 1927 should be OK.  Also can you get a safe for work avatar?
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: Gantry on 11/23/04, 11:48:19 AM
A little more info on contact rating...

http://dee-nee.com/rbi/faq.shtml#CONTACT
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: TecmoGuy on 11/23/04, 01:56:25 PM
I thnk the game needs to be hacked so we can have sweet leadoff hitters that always get a hit. Does rbi 2 or 3 have stats that reflect average?  I am seriously pissed that the original rbi never had average as a stat.  If average is not a stat, than its just HR derby all the time, isn't it?
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: ultimate7 on 11/23/04, 02:03:22 PM
I think speed is fairly important
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: BeefMaster on 11/23/04, 04:22:31 PM
Quote from: josephady on 11/23/04, 01:56:25 PM
I thnk the game needs to be hacked so we can have sweet leadoff hitters that always get a hit. Does rbi 2 or 3 have stats that reflect average?  I am seriously pissed that the original rbi never had average as a stat.  If average is not a stat, than its just HR derby all the time, isn't it?

Contact is supposed to reflect average.  That's as close as you're going to find.

In RBI 3, at least, contact rating is directly based on batting average.  Power is also directly based on homeruns for most players.
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: TecmoGuy on 11/23/04, 04:25:05 PM
cool, so that stat engine needs to be transferred to rbi 1.
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: ultimate7 on 11/23/04, 04:29:25 PM
Quote from: Gantry on 11/23/04, 11:48:19 AM
A little more info on contact rating...

http://dee-nee.com/rbi/faq.shtml#CONTACT
Joesphady, see this link, the contact rating is there, it just is not nearly as important as POWER in the game.

Make a ROM using very high contact ratings for low average hitters (maybe 99, I'm not sure how high it'll go) and you make have a more accurate reflection.
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: BeefMaster on 11/23/04, 04:40:42 PM
Quote from: josephady on 11/23/04, 04:25:05 PM
cool, so that stat engine needs to be transferred to rbi 1.

It's not the engine; it's just how the programmers assigned the ratings.  In the original, contact rating roughly corresponds to average, but they took some liberties with it, and there's no mathematical formula.  In RBI 3, it appears that players were ranked by league, with averages being mapped to contact ratings.  You could do the same if you were to make a ROM using the original.
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: TecmoGuy on 11/23/04, 04:55:15 PM
I have read that contact thing.  I want to make a rom where number one hitters can get a hit almost all the time, but never hit a Homer.  
Title: Re:If I guy has a good contact and shitty power, does he suck?
Post by: Dryden on 11/23/04, 05:39:12 PM
Give them insane speeds (like the heaven and hell ROM), 0 contact, and very (very) little power.  Every hit will be an infield single or a popout.  Of course, this also means they can score from first on a stolen base...