Dee-Nee Forums

General => RBI Baseball => Topic started by: Big Apple RBI Champ on 12/24/04, 08:42:41 AM

Title: NL All Star Review criticism
Post by: Big Apple RBI Champ on 12/24/04, 08:42:41 AM
Let me take issue with something said in the lineup review of NL All-Stars.  Mike Schmidt is "easily the worst player on this stellar team"?

Have you forgotten about Al Pedrique?

Other than that I think the reviews are of excellent quality.  I expect nothing less from the best RBI site on the web.

One other thing- I love Chester in 6 hole for Detroit.  Wouldn't even consider subbing Bergman.
Title: Re:NL All Star Review criticism
Post by: JoeDirt on 12/24/04, 11:27:52 AM
Agreed on the Lemon party issue.

Also, agreed on Schmidt--even if he did cry like Ryno after making sweet love.  Schmidt is better than the following NL "All Stars":

Pedrique
Sandberg
Santiago
Kruk
Gwynn
Gallaraga

So that leaves these as better than Schmidt:

Raines
Guerrero
Murphy
Dawson
Davis

...and that leaves Schmidt as a "middle of the road" NL player.