News:

RIP GoReds

Main Menu

The Worst RBI Clean up hitter

Started by ericdavisfan, 03/26/03, 01:54:28 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Who is the worst clean up hitter in RBI?

Glenn Davis
9 (75%)
Candy Maldonado
2 (16.7%)
Kent Hrbek
0 (0%)
Gary Carter
0 (0%)
Jim Rice
0 (0%)
Reggie Jackson
0 (0%)
Jack Clark
1 (8.3%)
Matt Nokes
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 10

ericdavisfan

I know that some of these guys don't belong on here, but I wanted to give everyone the choice rather than other.  I almost narrowed it down to two, but was curious to see the results of having all of them here (without all-stars)

GDavis


Gantry

I went years thinking Candy-man was the worst, but I have come around on him.  Geena is terrible, even worse considering he's the most powerful hitter on that team....


vgp100

You're going down, chainsaw.

ericdavisfan

Looks like I could have made it a two person survey after all.  I thought that there would be more dislike for the Candyman than this....sorry Glenn

Gantry

I too thought it wouldn't be such a runaway, though Geena is pretty bad.  Figured Carter would get at least one vote, I've never been a big fan.  But there are only 7 votes so far, I have faith non-Geenas will still get a couple votes...

GDavis

#6
No one has mentioned Nokes.  I think he's the 2nd worst on the list.

Edit: Nokes isn't on the list, but he bats clean up right?

Gantry

He sure is...  I changed the poll to list Nokes instead of Evans...

vgp100

What a shame. At the very least a team's cleanup should be sort of good. I don't even really like Jack Clark. As the only power hitter on that team, he should have much more power.
You're going down, chainsaw.

jcbball86

Gdavis is the worst and carter probably second, nokes isnt too bad, gets a homer sometimes.  jack clark i think is better than will, but they are both pretty equal and pretty good

ericdavisfan

Sorry about mixing up Darrell Evans and Matt Nokes.  I didn't even realize that I had put the wrong guy there.  Thank you, Gantry, for fixing it.  I had been gone for awhile and didn't see that somebody caught the error