Official "Dee-Nee-RBI'er hall of fame" selction thread.

[TbT]

Baylor is Bostons fastest guy and and most powerful.  whats wrong with that pick?

[Reds]

Baylor is Bostons fastest guy and and most powerful.  whats wrong with that pick?

meh....Mclane has some poopy pants tonight...

best player on my favorite team, i dont use all star squads so I decided I wouldnt vote for any of them...

[ultimate7]

Dawson
Reggie
Eric Davis
DaEvans
Blyleven
Bell

Changed my #6

[TbT]

noted....thanks.

[TbT]

best player on my favorite team, i dont use all star squads so I decided I wouldnt vote for any of them...

regardless of who you or i or anyone else for that matter selects, i think once its all said and done we'll all pretty much agree on the top 15 or so that make the HOF.  With a lot of people selecting so far this will all even out. im certain baylor will get in sooner or later.

[Medwck]

1. Reggie Jax
2. Roger 'Rocketman'
3. Ryan
4. Rice
5. Raines
6. Righetti

[TbT]

1. Reggie Jax
2. Roger 'Rocketman'
3. Ryan
4. Rice
5. Raines
6. Righetti

is this list brought to us by seasame street? 

[malnuboy]

1: "Digital" Don Baylor

2: Doc Gooden

3: Bert Blyleven

4: Jim Rice

5: Vince Coleman

6: Reggie Jackson

[Attezz]

1: Tudor (seriously, what the fuck McLane?)
2: Kirk Gibson
3: Chili Davis
4: Bert Blyleven
5: Tom Brunansky
6: Kirby Puckett

[ultimate7]

Seriously, how do multiple people have Kirby in their top 6 players

[Attezz]

He got 1 point from me, it's not as if it'll make a difference.

[TbT]

Seriously, how do multiple people have Kirby in their top 6 players

He got 1 point from me, it's not as if it'll make a difference.

Attez is right on.  1 point isnt gonna screw up anything at this phase.  Puckett sees better pitches than the others top 5 batters when i play MIN.  If this happens to Attez then maybe Pucket plays a big role in creating some runs when he uses MIN.

I got no problem with an occasional seemingly odd selection as the last pick.  I think they are kind of interesting to see whos a family member or whatever gantry calls it.

[JoeDirt]

1. (6 pts) John Tudor
2. (5 pts) Jesse Orosco
3. (4 pts) Roger Clemens
4. (3 pts) George Bell
5. (2 pts) Mark McGwire
6. (1  pt)  Andre Dawson

[Stock]

1 (6 points)- Mark McGwire
2 (5 points)- Reggie Jackson
3 (4 points)-Nolan Ryan
4 (3 points)-Dawson
5 (2 points)-Gibson
6 (1 point)-Blyleven

2. (5 pts) Jesse Orosco

WTF??  Did JD just give us the secret to his success??

[TbT]

lefty sidearmer.  probably just a rarity.

[ultimate7]

Anyone putting a relief pitcher on their list is also making a mockery of the HOF, how can we expect people to take us seriously

[Stock]

Anyone putting a relief pitcher on their list is also making a mockery of the HOF, how can we expect people to take us seriously

No shit.  Why not vote in Dan Plesac while we are at it.

[TbT]

Anyone putting a relief pitcher on their list is also making a mockery of the HOF, how can we expect people to take us seriously

thats a good point because they play a smaller role than most anyone else, but i stand by my pick of wilie hernandez.  *edit* Now that ive thought about it for a while, o think i stand behind my pick even more.  unlike real baseball, in RBI a guy like Dayley, Hernandez, or Orosco can easily play in every game that you use those teams.  Orosco is my starter almost 90% of the time.  Hernandez is almost always my 2nd guy to come in regardless of my opponent.  To me those 2 are staples in my rotation when using NY and DET.     

Hernandez and Tim McKyer of SF Tecmo Bowl fame is a bastard who riddles my exsistence to this day.   Those 2 are in a daily car crash in the epicenter of my brain, and thers nothing i can do about it.

[broiler]

1.Mark McGwire
2.Andre Dawson
3.Mike Krukow
4.Dale Murphy
5.Tony Armas
6.Jimmy Key

[Clambutt]

1. Reggie Jax
2. Roger 'Rocketman'
3. Ryan
4. Rice
5. Raines
6. Righetti

is this list brought to us by the letter R r?