Home Run Derby Rules

[Gantry]

That's a great point GDavis, perhaps we need to do it blind or rock-paper-scissors...

[sucka free]

I'm not sold on a player having an advantag going second.  I think that htere are plus and minus in going first or second.  

Advantages in going first:
1.  No pressure of catching up
2.  More relaxed hitting enviroment
3.  YOU GET TO MAKE YOUR OPPONENT DRINK BEFORE HE MAKES YOU DRINK!!!!!

Advantages in going second:
1.  You know how many HR you need
2.  Posibble line up adjustments

[Vitb6]

On my last post I fucked up.  I DIDN'T re-read it (thanks to my thread) and just caught something.  I think that people should NOT drink in the tourney.  It is a tie-breaker only.  People already drank the required amount and this tie-breaking system shouldn't include drinking just because there is a tie.

[sucka free]

I think that drinking should be doubled because it is a tie-breaker.  Vit, how can you have a HR derby with ou drinking?   I just don't get it.

[Lips]

As the Dee-Nee tourney looms near, we are still trying to figure out a consensus tie-breaker.  So I figured I would bump this thread...