RBI's All-Time Team - General Messages

[dvldog]

A lot of these were really close, but I think it's about time to start calling some of the races - not all of them, but some of those which have been up for a while.... sorry if you didn't get a chance to vote.

Some results needed to be explained, but I will take them out soon to keep it from looking messy.

First Team
C - Matt Nokes
1B - Darrell Evans
2B - Lou Whitaker
3B - Gary Gaetti
SS - Alan Trammel
RF -
CF -
LF -

PH -
PH -
PH -
PH -

SP - Doc Gooden (edged out Ryan with comments)
SP - Nolan Ryan
RP - Jesse Orosco
RP - Juan Berenguer

Second-Team
C - Gary Carter
1B - Will Clark
2B - Tommy Herr (tied with Thompson and Backman; Backman received no comments, while you guys thrashed Thompson - Herr was the only one with a positve comment rating in the end.)
3B - DeCinces
SS - Ozzie Smith
RF -
CF -
LF -

PH -
PH -
PH -
PH -

SP - Clemens
SP - Tudor (tied with Krukow, but Tudor received more positive comments - yup, that's what it came down to)
RP - Hernandez
RP - Moore

[Gantry]

I would break down OFs by position in the RBI manual, for consistency's sake.  The manual may be off at a couple OF positions, but then again there aren't really positions in RBI anyway...

I'd go righty and lefty for starting pitchers, ditto for relievers.  Though I personally feel that 3 rightys and one lefty is a perfect staff.  Two leftys is too much - so I guess it's debatable...

[doveRBI]

The scope of this enormous project is awesome.  It reminds me of the heady days of the Dee-Nee vs. Dah-Nah project.  Still waiting to see that Rom and the t-shirt dedicated to it!

[Gantry]

At least let the polls run through midnight Sunday.  I thik there might be some weekend stragglers out there.  Give them their shot...

[Gantry]

It's your baby dvldog and most of the main votes are in.  Any stragglers probably wouldn't have changed the outcome.  Top-notch job so far, I'll add a table on my Rankings page to include the winners.....

[fknmclane]

Tudor.  Wooooooooooooooooo!

Doesn't Tommy Him play 3B?  Or am I just on another Dove quality binge?

[fknmclane]

Again, I'm proving I'm the biggest retard on this site.  I voted for Pendleton at third and yet I'm questioning if someone else plays there.  I guess I'm just think of Him's batting position.  Damn, I can't wait for this semester to finish up.

[vgp100]

I don't agree with the Robbie Thompson stuff. I made a comment about the guy--but I didn't trash him. He's got a couple of HR's on my RBI fantasy team. I think he should get a fair shot at 2nd team all RBI.  Maybe a coin toss or something.