Official "Dee-Nee-RBI'er hall of fame" selction thread--PART 2 ELECTRIC BOOGALOO

[AlecTrevylan006]

This is actually even more reason to vote FOR the guy.  You're saying that if he gets on base his team wins.  Can't say that about many players in RBI except for maybe Lopes and Raines, right?

If Lopes were credited with a triple in every at bat, Houston might still be the worst team in the game though >_>

[fknmclane]

This is true.  But my  point still stands.

[TbT]

Im not saying getting Vince on garantees a win.  I am saying that keeping him off base practically garantees a loss.

Sorta like saying in baseball...good pitching doesnt neccesarily garantees you'll win, but bad pitching does garantee you wont win.

[Darky]

Reggie Jackson, Andre Dawson, Mark Mcgwire and Darrel Evans


1 (6 points)- Dale Murphy
2 (5 points)- Chili Davis
3 (4 points)- Tim Raines
4 (3 points)- Tony Armas
5 (2 points)- The Straw
6 (1 point)- Mike Krukow

[broiler]

orosco is a horrible pitcher

[The Express]

who actually wants to count all this up...

[TbT]

thats my job.  bowl season is laying the smack down on my daily duties.  I got an hour or 2 of free time here this after noon, i'll see if i can get it all together.

[broiler]

get on it, slacker

[The Express]

bored at work... i guess i'll do it

[broiler]

anyone want to bet on who will have it done first?

[TbT]

i'm working on this between tecmo games.....

unofficial numbers so far

Raines 38
Bell 34
Armas 32
Tudor 29
Baylor 29
Murphy 26
E Davis 25
Strawberry 18
Burks 12
Rice 10

back to counting..........

[TbT]

more votes....
Ryan 20
Gibson 20
Blyleven 12
Gooden 11
Canseco 10
Clemens 10

just looking over my sheets here...apears that we have all the major vote getters accounted for.......more tecmo for an hour then back to tallying.

[The Express]

unofficially, here's my count... someone can double check if they want

tim raines
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (37)

George Bell
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (34)

Tony Armas
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (31)

Don Baylor
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (29)

John Tudor
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (29)

dale murphy
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Eric Davis
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Darryl Strawberry
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Nolan Ryan
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

mike krukow
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Kirk Gibson
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Chili Davis
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

"ellis" Burks
xxxxxxxxxxxx

Jack Clark
xxxxxxx

Jesse Orosco
xx

Keith Hernandez
x

Spike Owen
xxxxxx

Glen Davis
xxxx

Terry Puhl
xxx
xx

Mike Scott
xx

jimmy key
xxx

will clark
xxxxxx

Ruppert Jones
xxxxxx

Jesse Orosco
xxxxx

Roger Clemens
xxxxxxxxxx

Blyleven
xxxxxxxxxxxx

Kirby Puckett
xxxxx

Vince Coleman
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Pat Sheridan
xxxxxxxxx

Tom Brunanski
xxxxxxx

Sandberg
x

Joyner
xxxxx

Gaetti
x

gooden
xxxxxxxx

rice
x
xxxx

canseco
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Saber
xxxx

Fernando Valenzuela
xxxxxxx

Alan Trammell
xxxxxxx

Steve Bedrosian
x

Harry Spilman
xx

Heep
xxxxxx

Brett
xxxxx

Seitzer
xxxx

[The Express]

do you play tecmo on nesticle online at all?

[TbT]

cant say i have.

[broiler]

some of the numbers dont jive

[nomaaa]

some of the numbers dont jive

two out of five is definitely jive.

[TbT]

since bdawk voted for 2 guys that were already in(jackson/mcgwire?) then didnt respond to a pm or change his votes i just slid those guys all up to a 1-4 voting.  thats probably the difference.

also tudor and baylor are tied for 4th place.  what do we do?  baylor was on 8 ballots and Tudor was on 6.  anyone got any ideas how we decide this?  perhaps make an open puhl on dee-nee for everyone to vote?  or just say fuck it, its close enough and let em both in?

[Attezz]

I saw we give it to Tudor, since he's more worthy

[nomaaa]

i say you take bdawks votes as 3-4-5-6 instead, and see how that changes things.