Dee-Nee decides the RBI HOF'ers.

[TbT]

We should induct a handful of the best RBI'ers into a "Dee-Nee hall of fame".

Im thinking maybe each forum user can submit 5 players ranked 1 thru 5.  the players ranked 1 get 5 points, and 2 gets 4 and so on.  Then we tally up the votes and the top 3, or 4 get in.  This would be based off thier RBI playing ability, and not real life stats and such.  I suggest this be done once a year(january works).

Anyways lets get some input and then we can go from here and make an "Official" thread for this once we know what we want to do.

uh...this is ok with Gantry right?   to add another page to dee-nee for this crap?   

DISCUSS!

[Attezz]

1: John Tudor
2: Ellis Burks
3: Kirk Gibson
4: Chili Davis
5: Vince Coleman


I have no idea how to play this game.

[TbT]

good enuf.  I'll make note of your choices once we arrange an official thread. just looking for more ideas on how to do this for now.  if you like later, you can change your selections.

[Attezz]

I'll definitely change my choices later, what if we didn't have to rank them and possibly had 2 pitcher selections and 5 hitter selections?

[TbT]

yah know, thats not a bad idea.  we'll throw that around into the equation.

the ranking just gives players a point total, to see how high the rate with everyone. 

[BDawk]

Kirk gibson

[moses]

So TBT have you decided your choices yet?

[RedBarron]

you need registered voters, ballots, and rules.

[TβG]

andre dawson

also, is this watchgame HOF?  straight pitch?   ATG?

[TbT]

andre dawson

also, is this watchgame HOF?  straight pitch?   ATG?

good points.  this throws a dang wrench in there.  Im thinking ATG, is the actual barometer of RBI.  with that said, regardless of how you play, the guys who get voted in will need to get the most votes so it should all worjk out in the end.

[Attezz]

I would like to propose that Jim Rice not be allowed to get into the hall of fame.

[nomaaa]

should spike owen take his place then?

[Caveman]

1 - Reggie Jackson
2 - Frank Viola
3 - Jim Rice
4 - Steve Bedrosian
5 - Kevin Mitchell

[broiler]

1. will clark
2. mike krukow
3. reggie jackson
4. tim raines
5. rob wilfong

[RedBarron]

Andre Dawson
Ruppert Jones
Kevin McReynolds
Nolan Ryan
Ricky Henderson

[fknmclane]

How many guys will get in?  This won't last long if you're putting in five guys a year.  That said:

-Andre Dawson
-Jorge Bell
-John Tudor
-Chili Davis
-Tony Pena

[Gantry]

Any ballot that does not have Potatoes is void...  Me tyrant