Name the Player

[BeefMaster]

I know Hack Wilson is one of the arcade ones.

Kevin Mitchell is my NES guess.

[fknmclane]

George Bell.

[Gantry]

No clue but I'm going Canseco & Jim Rice - this is before the warnings so I don't cheat

[ultimate7]

I know Hack Wilson is one of the arcade ones.

1 Arcade, I think there are 8 or so

no one has gotten the other NES

[Gantry]

Without looking at the rosters:

Hack Wilson
Lou Gehrig
Frank Robinson
Ted Williams (since Rice is wrong)
Hank Aaron


God this is hard...

[Gantry]

Maybe McGwire for Stl?  I thought it had to be the same team, but since Baylor counts...

[BeefMaster]

Semi-crazy guess - Ellis Burks for the Rockies.

[Attezz]

Glenn Davis.

[Gantry]

If McGwire isn't right, I'm going with George Brett. 

[ultimate7]

Without looking at the rosters:

Hack Wilson
Lou Gehrig
Frank Robinson
Ted Williams (since Rice is wrong)
Hank Aaron

Gehrig and Wilson (already named by Beef) are correct.  No one else is correct yet.

2 Arcade (Gehrig, Wilson)
1 of 2 NES (Baylor)

Have been named

[Mike D.]

Mike Schmidt?

Tony Armas?

Chili Davis?

[defen]

Dawson for the Expos?

[ultimate7]

No, No, No, No

[edfan]

Pedro Guerrero, Dodgers

[BeefMaster]

More NES guesses:

Galarraga for the Rockies
Murphy for the Braves
Eric Davis for the Reds

[edfan]

Is George Foster one of the Arcade guys?


edit...Jimmie Foxx has to be on there too

[ultimate7]

More NES guesses:

Galarraga for the Rockies

Winner

[ultimate7]

Is George Foster one of the Arcade guys?


edit...Jimmie Foxx has to be on there too

Yes and Yes (Foxx for RedSox and A's)

[Gantry]

Medwick for the Cards?  Won a triple crown...

[ultimate7]

Medwick for the Cards?  Won a triple crown...

correct, and there are at least 1 more Arcade