Fantasy RBI 2017 Discussion Thread

[Darky]

Yeah, you can't replay the whole season. The only thing I can do is step in for trades that can affect future games, and it's clear Darky doesn't want these trades to happen, nor are they good for the league.

I'm not saying to replay any games, but make reset the rosters for week 4 to the original drafted rosters.  Be fair and balanced here.

I'm in favor of this. Let the records stand and reset to the original rosters with all teams that traded with the Empire. This way we all have our original rosters that we drafted, the suspense would be recreated, and we can just play ball with our drafted men starting from week 4. That sounds fair and balanced to me since it's still real early in the season and the people I traded with clearly gained a big advantage from my moments of insanity. Nacho's team gains an advantage from the fallout here if the rosters aren't reset mainly because DCincs tips the odds too far in his favor. McLane wouldn't be affected if Garner went back to his bench either.

[Nacho]

So a team makes a trade, the trade stands for the length of time for the players to play a game or two, and then the players have to go back to playing for their original teams? I don't think that's every happened before. Sounds pretty ridiculous.

[Shooty]

The point is Darky made a lot of dumb trades.  Either they should all stand or none of them.  Why do other teams get the benefit of the moves but I don't?  It seems to be purely because mine were the most recent.  Doesn't make any sense.  None of the individual trades are vetoable.  They just look bad on Darky when you look at the outcome of all his moves combined.  Fighton already said he wasn't going to veto the Baylor trade, so to go back now and reverse it is also a goofy response.  If he wants to veto the Whitaker for Herr trade, then he has that option, but changing his mind on the Baylor deal because the Whitaker/Herr trade also happened is absent of logic.

So really the only logical/fair options are:
1) Reserve all trades Darky made and block him from trading again
2) Let all the trades stand
3) Veto the Herr/Whitaker deal

I'm hoping fighton changes his stance and makes a more rational decision that isn't so Anti-Canadian.

[Nacho]

I'd be fine with just vetoing the Herr/Whitaker trade, since that's the only one that's really egregious.

[Man of Steal]

LET THEM STAND

[Darky]

So really the only logical/fair option is:
1) Reverse all trades Darky made and block him from trading again

Most logical, fair, and balanced. I was momentarily insane and going through PTSD, and no man in his right mind would do that.

[Reds]

Let them fucking stand, and then ban darky from future fantasy rbi.  If he wants to act like a twat, we shouldnt punish shooty. 

[Man of Steal]

Let them fucking stand, and then ban darky from future fantasy rbi.  If he wants to act like a twat, we shouldnt punish shooty. 

[GDavis]

Make Herr yours

[nomaaa]

Make Herr yours

crunchy

[Shooty]

So fighton, what's your final decision now?

[fightonusc]

I already made my final decision. Darky's trades from after Week 3 that would have taken place in Week 4 are voided. Any trades with Darky must be cleared with the Commissioner before being announced. Note: previous trades that have been voided can be resubmitted and will be considered on a case-by-case basis.

[Shooty]

So the Brett for Garner trade is also vetoed?

[Darky]

So the Brett for Garner trade is also vetoed?

Any chance I get DCincs back? That would mean Brett would go back to Nacho and Garner back to McLane. Burks can stay with Nacho.

DCincs power rating is like 60 pts higher than Brett's and over 80 than Knight or Garner who are on my roster. I plead momentarily insanity for that trade. Again, Nacho can keep Burks.

[GDavis]

this is dumb

[Shooty]

this is dumb

Agreed.  None of fighton's decision makes a lick of sense. 

[nomaaa]

i propose we go back and replay week 2 & beyond.

[Shooty]

So the Brett for Garner trade is also vetoed?

Any chance I get DCincs back? That would mean Brett would go back to Nacho and Garner back to McLane. Burks can stay with Nacho.

DCincs power rating is like 60 pts higher than Brett's and over 80 than Knight or Garner who are on my roster. I plead momentarily insanity for that trade. Again, Nacho can keep Burks.

This is my point.  You (Darky) made a lot of dumb trades.  Fighton is arbitrarily reversing some and not others.  Its goofy.  If he was OK with the Garner for Brett trade before, why would subsequent dumb trades by Darky then change his mind?  Same with the Baylor/Pena for Nokes/Hendrick trade which he was fine with.  The Herr for Whitaker trade should be the only one reversed since people really didn't like it (rightfully so). 

And don't get me wrong, I'm not arguing this because of the impact on my team (I am perfectly OK with reversing all of Darky's trades) and going back to our original drafted lineups.  I just dislike illogical decisions. 

[Nacho]

i propose we go back and replay week 2 & beyond.

No.

[Nacho]

Any chance I get DCincs back?

No.