Official "Dee-Nee-RBI'er hall of fame" selction thread.

[TbT]

Can we get a sticky for this?
The rules and regulations. 

This thread will be open for ballots cast for the nes RBI players from all 10 teams until 12 AM monday january 29th 2007.  You are allowed to vote for your top 6 RBI'ers.  The vote will include a points scale which is as follows.

1st selection is worth 6 points
2nd selection is worth 5 points
3rd selection is worth 4 points....and so on and so forth through the 6 selections.  Please list your top candidate as #1, and 2nd candidate as #2.  For ease just copy and paste my top 6, then change the player names to fit your list.

This will be the 1st ballot and the players with the top 4 number of votes will all be inducted into the Dee-Nee Hall of RBI fame.  Im hoping to get ballots from at least 30-35 Dee-nee'ers here but definitley want more, so rock the vote people. 

You can create your list anyway you see fit, but please NO Joke lists like rapheal santana and periq.  Any style of play can be taken into consideration such as anything goes, straight pitch, or slurve, and also 1 or 2 starting pitcher games.  There are plenty of angles you can take to create your list.  A players performance for you, or his impact on his team based on his spot in the order, or which side he bats from in relation to his team.  Player ratings can be used, or those bench guys that play a key role.  And dont forget about those nasty starters and key set up men that get you through the meat of the order in crucial situations.   

February 1st will be the official induction day for the 4 RBI'ers who are elected.  Im pushing for another ballot in mid-late july.  We will also have to decide on a cap or total number of players who can get in.  possibly 20. 

I'll start off with my 6 selection.
1 (6 points)- Darrell Evans
2 (5 points)- Mark Mcgwire
3 (4 points)-Bert Blyleven
4 (3 points)-Tony Armas
5 (2 points)-John Tudor
6 (1 point)-Willie Hernandez

Next....

[Necrophobic]

1 (6 points)- Dwight Gooden
2 (5 points)- Nolan Ryan
3 (4 points)- Reggie Jackson
4 (3 points)- Roger Clemens
5 (2 points)- John Tudor
6 (1 point)-  Kirby Puckett

Next....

[Clambutt]

1 (6) R.Jackson
2 (5) D.Strawberry
3 (4) D.Baylor
4 (3) K.Gibson
5 (2) N.Ryan
6 (1) B.Blyleven

[Shooty]

1. Andre Dawson
2. Mark McGwire
3. DaEvans
4. Dwight Gooden
5. Reggie Jackson
6. Eric Davis

[Nails]

1. Gooden
2. Dawson
3. DaEvans
4. Jackson
5. N.Ryan
6. Strawberry

[Gantry]

1 (6 points)- Reggie Jackson
2 (5 points)- Darrell Evans
3 (4 points)- Andre Dawson
4 (3 points)- Darryl Strawberry
5 (2 points)- Roger Clemens
6 (1 point)- Kirk Gibson

[OctoFranco]

1 (6 points)- Darryl Strawberry
2 (5 points)- Tony Armas
3 (4 points)- Reggie Jackson
4 (3 points)- Bert Blyleven
5 (2 points)- Roger Clemens
6 (1 point)- Tim Raines

Honorable mention: Tom Brookens

PS. Hey wow, we brought Nails out of the woodwork ...

...

...

No pun intended.

[ultimate7]

Dawson
Reggie
Eric Davis
DaEvans
Blyleven
McGwire

[Caveman]

1. Reggie Jackson
2. McGwire
3. Strawberry
4. Ryan
5. Clemens
6. V. Coleman

[nomaaa]

1. doc gooden
2. matt nokes reggie jackson
3. tony armas
4. roger clemens
5. eric davis
6. ellis burks

[fightonusc]

1.   Andre Dawson
2.   Mark McGwire
3.   Reggie Jackson
4.   Darrell Evans
5.   George Bell
6.   Chili Davis

[ultimate7]

Can we edit our picks or are they set in stone once we post?

[Mike D.]

1.   Andre Dawson
2.   Tony Armas
3.   Reggie Jackson
4.   Darrell Evans
5.   George Bell
6.   Bret Saberhagen

[fknmclane]

1.   Andre Dawson
2.   Mark McGwire
3.   Reggie Jackson
4.   Darrell Evans
5.   George Bell
6.   Chili Davis

[TbT]

Can we edit our picks or are they set in stone once we post?

edit  if you'd like.  ive made a spreadsheet that im using to tally things with, but it'll be easy enuf to change

nice picks by fighton and miked as were getting some new names who are definitely worthy of at least a mention befores its all said and done.

This is turning out to be a very interesting.  without checking i got some ideas of who could be in the lead, but it seems theres about 3 guys all neck and neck for the top vote getter.

[camuyarenas]

1 (6 points)- Reggie Jackson
2 (5 points)- Kirk Gibson
3 (4 points)- Darrell Evans
4 (3 points)- Roger Clemens
5 (2 points)- Nolan Ryan
6 (1 point)- Alan Trammell

[Reds]

1 (6 points)- Reggie Jackson
2 (5 points)- Kirk Gibson
3 (4 points)- Darrell Evans
4 (3 points)- Roger Clemens
5 (2 points)- Nolan Ryan
6 (1 point)- Alan Trammell

Does this guy really get a say in this?  I mean he has 17 posts...


anyways.

1.  Darrell Evans
2.  Don Baylor
3.  Roger Clemens
4.  Rupert Jones
5.  Darryl Strawberry
6.  Mike Scott

[TbT]

yeah hes alright.  3 of his 6 are probably locks to enter just by half ass looking at whos been selected.   Trammel is the only guy on his list thats not been voted for just yet.

[fknmclane]

1 (6 points)- Reggie Jackson
2 (5 points)- Kirk Gibson
3 (4 points)- Darrell Evans
4 (3 points)- Roger Clemens
5 (2 points)- Nolan Ryan
6 (1 point)- Alan Trammell

Does this guy really get a say in this?  I mean he has 17 posts...


anyways.

1.  Darrell Evans
2.  Don Baylor
3.  Roger Clemens
4.  Rupert Jones
5.  Darryl Strawberry
6.  Mike Scott

Does GoReds really have a say in this?  I mean, he voted for Don fucking Baylor at number 2?

[JerryD]

1) Dawson
2) McGwire
3) Jackson
4) Canseco
5) Clemens
6) Gibson